
Pen Chalet Pen Cache Mystery Box Fountain Pens

X


About the Pen Chalet Pen Cache Mystery Box
Pen Cache Mystery Box: Saturday Morning Shenanigans Edition – September 2026
No alarm. No agenda. Possibly cartoons.
The Pen Cache Mystery Box: Saturday Morning Shenanigans Edition is colorful, cheerful, slightly ridiculous, and inspired by Saturday mornings when the only real plan is to have absolutely no plan.
This playful Pen Cache starts with the essentials for a very good writing day: a fun fountain pen, a full-size bottle of colorful fountain pen ink, and a bright pen accessory. Then we added a few custom Pen Chalet pieces.
And then, frankly, things got a little silly.
Every box also contains one ridiculous little Saturday Shenanigan. It serves no essential writing purpose. You don't need it. We refuse to defend it. And we're definitely not telling you which one you're getting.
What Can You Expect in the September 2026 Pen Cache Mystery Box?
We'll give you this much:
Pen details, ink selections, accessory colors, and Saturday Shenanigan surprises are intentionally assorted. Your particular combination remains a mystery until you open the box.
It could even be said that we packed a little bit of a pen party in this box.
This is not the Mystery Box for taking your stationery hobby terribly seriously. It's for playing with ink, writing something purely because you feel like it, and remembering that pens are supposed to be fun...like Saturday morning cartoons in your pajamas with your favorite bowl of cereal.
Estimated Retail Value: $74.99
Your Price: $39.99
Only 23 Saturday Morning Shenanigans Pen Cache Mystery Boxes are available. Once the shenanigans are gone, they're gone.
More About the Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes:
Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes are limited-edition themed releases created for pen lovers who enjoy a great writing experience and a genuinely good surprise. Each edition brings together carefully selected writing instruments, inks, accessories, stationery, collectibles, or other finds around a new theme.
We provide enough clues to help you choose your adventure, but exact products, brands, colors, and variations remain a mystery until your box arrives.
In the spirit of “NO PEEKING,” don't try to trick your favorite Pen Chalet employee into revealing the secrets of the Mystery Box. That spoils all the fun.
But DO share once yours arrives. Everyone loves to see a good mystery solved in the end.
Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes are limited edition and available only while supplies last.
We don't accept returns on Mystery Boxes. However, if you have a problem with your pen or receive a defective item, that's a different story. Please reach out to customer service so we can take care of you.
No alarm. No agenda. Possibly cartoons.
The Pen Cache Mystery Box: Saturday Morning Shenanigans Edition is colorful, cheerful, slightly ridiculous, and inspired by Saturday mornings when the only real plan is to have absolutely no plan.
This playful Pen Cache starts with the essentials for a very good writing day: a fun fountain pen, a full-size bottle of colorful fountain pen ink, and a bright pen accessory. Then we added a few custom Pen Chalet pieces.
And then, frankly, things got a little silly.
Every box also contains one ridiculous little Saturday Shenanigan. It serves no essential writing purpose. You don't need it. We refuse to defend it. And we're definitely not telling you which one you're getting.
What Can You Expect in the September 2026 Pen Cache Mystery Box?
We'll give you this much:
- 1 playful fountain pen with plenty of Saturday-morning personality
- 1 full-size bottle of colorful fountain pen ink
- 1 bright pen pouch or writing accessory
- 1 Saturday Shenanigan Surprise — a completely unnecessary little piece of nonsense
- 1 colorful little extra for your stationery stash
- 1 custom Saturday Morning Shenanigans Writing & Journaling Prompt Card
- 1 custom Saturday Morning Shenanigans Story Card
Pen details, ink selections, accessory colors, and Saturday Shenanigan surprises are intentionally assorted. Your particular combination remains a mystery until you open the box.
It could even be said that we packed a little bit of a pen party in this box.
This is not the Mystery Box for taking your stationery hobby terribly seriously. It's for playing with ink, writing something purely because you feel like it, and remembering that pens are supposed to be fun...like Saturday morning cartoons in your pajamas with your favorite bowl of cereal.
Estimated Retail Value: $74.99
Your Price: $39.99
Only 23 Saturday Morning Shenanigans Pen Cache Mystery Boxes are available. Once the shenanigans are gone, they're gone.
More About the Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes:
Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes are limited-edition themed releases created for pen lovers who enjoy a great writing experience and a genuinely good surprise. Each edition brings together carefully selected writing instruments, inks, accessories, stationery, collectibles, or other finds around a new theme.
We provide enough clues to help you choose your adventure, but exact products, brands, colors, and variations remain a mystery until your box arrives.
In the spirit of “NO PEEKING,” don't try to trick your favorite Pen Chalet employee into revealing the secrets of the Mystery Box. That spoils all the fun.
But DO share once yours arrives. Everyone loves to see a good mystery solved in the end.
Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes are limited edition and available only while supplies last.
We don't accept returns on Mystery Boxes. However, if you have a problem with your pen or receive a defective item, that's a different story. Please reach out to customer service so we can take care of you.
Product Specifications
Nib Material: Stainless Steel
Available Sizes & Colors
- Pen Chalet Pen Cache Mystery Box Fountain Pens - Pen Cache / M nib - Medium (Stainless Steel nib) *
* Special orders typically ship in 14-21 business days. However, occasionally due to manufacturer inventory, items can take up to 1-3 months. For a specific shipping estimate on your special order contact Customer Care.
Guaranteed Quality
Each Pen Chalet Pen Cache Mystery Box Fountain Pens we sell is guaranteed to be genuine, authentic and will arrive brand new & unused!
Pen Chalet Pen Cache Mystery Box Reviews
I have ordered a handful of Mystery Boxes over the past year from Pen Chalet, but sadly I have to say this latest one, the Saturday Morning Shenanigans Edition Pen Cache Mystery Box, was a dud. I loved the pen I received (Kaweco), but the other items were just "meh." The ink wasn't a particularly great color (for me at least), and I was deeply disappointed to discover one of the special items called out was a paper clip. Not a small box of paperclips, or a little envelope with a handful of paperclips, but a single paperclip. It was admittedly a uniquely shaped paperclip, but it was still just a paperclip. I know Mystery Boxes are always a gamble, but this is the first one I have purchased from them where I have to say I don't feel like I got my money's worth.
2
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
The box contained my first Nahvalur/ Narwal pen, an original demonstrator version. I liked it so much that I bought more Nahvalur fountain pens! Wasn’t sure at first about the Nahvalur Orchid ink, but after using it for a while, I decided I like it too.
The price to value ratio was great, and I received products that I would not have otherwise considered. Thanks for introducing me to some great products!
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
This was a super fun mystery box to open! Loved the pen and the goodies I received.
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
What a great experience. Not only did I get some lovely products that are worth more than I paid, I got an extra sample of the limited edition "Headless Horseman" ink which goes so well with halloween-themed fountain pens!
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
I've purchased several Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes and have never been disappointed. The summer 2025 knocked my socks off! This is definitely on my short list any time a new Mystery Box drops!
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
You never know what you are going to get in the mystery box, but you won't ever be disappointed!
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
Loved all the items. Great value and so much fun!
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
I've never bought a 'mystery box' before because I know what I like and usually don't want to experiment outside that, but the low price of this box compared to others I'd seen made it feel like a low risk.
But when it arrived, I was so pleasantly surprised. My box came with a PanAm branded notebook, a pair of envelope-shaped paper clips in a nice copper color, a full-size bottle of Private Reserve ink (that will probably last me the rest of my life, it's that big) and the new Monteverde MP1 fountain pen. I've had poor experiences with Monteverde pens before so I was hesitant, but the MP1 works great for me - a smooth writer with a large ink capacity. The locked piston is a good idea in general, but not for the reason listed - the cap does not post securely due to it being a screw-on cap. The threads don't lock on to anything if you post it, so the whole "locked piston so you can post" marketing is a gimmick. Still, in all other ways it's a good pen, that I never would have bought for myself and am glad to now own.
I'll mostly likey get another mystery box in the future.
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
The pen is nice, keeps the ink off my hands plus feels great in the hand. The ink is good, but no special properties like sheen or glitter. The paper feels good, but OMG the PanAm styling!
4
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
I got this mystery box as a midwinter treat/pick-me-up and it didn't disappoint! In the box were three FP themed stickers, some cute cat paperclips, a bottle of Private Reserve ink and a fine nib Monteverde MP1 fountain pen. This is my first Monteverde, and I'm absolutely thrilled! This pen writes smoother than any other of the 20+ pens I own, even the ones costing 3-4x as much. I literally can't explain how smoothly this pen writes - as soon as the nib hits paper the ink flows with absolutely no pressure. I'm really looking forward to using it to take minutes during an hours long hearing I have tonight. Usually my wrist is aching after such long writing sessions, but I have a feeling that'll be a problem of the past with this pen.
So, if you need an excuse to treat yo' self, this is it! Either grab a mystery box or go straight for the Monteverde MP1...no matter what, you won't be disappointed!
5
out of 5

quality:

function:

style:

value:

quality:
function:
style:
value:
FAQs about the Pen Chalet Pen Cache Mystery Box
Ask your own question:
Product out of stock
Notify me when this item is back in stock.

Unsure which nib size to choose? We can help...










Ink Rewards
Easy Returns