100% Satisfaction Guarantee - Easy Returns

Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens

Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain PensPreviousNext
Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens in Pen Pals / B nibPen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens in Pen Pals / EF nibPen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens in Pen Pals / F nibPen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens in Pen Pals / FlexPen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens in Pen Pals / M nibPen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens in Pen Pals / Stub nib
X
PreviousNext14241-PenPalsBnib
Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box  Fountain Pens pen_chalet_pen_pals_mystery_box_letters_of_liberty_edition_fountain_pens
pen_chalet_pen_pals_mystery_box_letters_of_liberty_edition_fountain_pens
pen_pals_mystery_boxes


expand

About the Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box

Pen Pals Mystery Box: Letters of Liberty Edition – November 2026

Some stories deserve to be written. Some words deserve to be remembered.

In a year marking 250 years of American independence, we're honoring the written word, the stories that shape our lives, and the people who have served to protect our freedoms.

Introducing the Pen Pals Mystery Box: Letters of Liberty Fountain Pen Edition, a special commemorative release created for Veterans Day 2026.

At the heart of this edition is a limited-edition fountain pen featuring custom red, white, and blue resin created to commemorate America's 250th anniversary. We've paired this collectible writing instrument with a hand-selected full-size bottle of fountain pen ink, quality writing paper, and exclusive Pen Chalet commemorative inserts.

It's a celebration of history, handwriting, gratitude, and the stories we choose to preserve.

Of course, this is still a Mystery Box. The exact fountain pen model, ink color, and writing paper selection will remain a surprise until yours arrives!

What's Inside the Letters of Liberty Fountain Pen Mystery Box?

We've kept a few details under wraps, but here's what every box is guaranteed to include:

  • 1 limited-edition fountain pen featuring custom USA 250 commemorative resin in red, white, and blue (retail value $215 or more)

  • 1 full-size bottle of fountain pen ink in a hand-selected shade of red or blue, from Private Reserve or Monteverde (retail value $18 or more)

  • 1 quality fountain pen-friendly notebook or notepad, selected from a variety of brands, sizes, and styles (retail value $7 or more)

  • 1 custom Letters of Liberty Commemorative Story Card, sharing the inspiration behind this special edition

  • 1 exclusive Letters of Liberty Journaling Prompt Card No. 007, featuring five thoughtful writing prompts inspired by gratitude, courage, freedom, and legacy



Two Limited-Edition Designs. One Commemorative Collection. Which One Will You Discover?

Each box contains one of two limited-edition fountain pen designs featuring the same extraordinary red, white, and blue anniversary resin. The design you receive is part of the mystery.

Whether you're a dedicated fountain pen collector, a history enthusiast, or someone who believes that handwritten words have a special kind of power, this edition offers a meaningful addition to your collection.

Expect something collectible. Expect a beautiful writing experience. Expect an invitation to put pen to paper.

Just don't expect us to reveal all the details before you open your box!

Guaranteed Retail Value: $240+

Letters of Liberty Fountain Pen Mystery Box Price: $124.99

Limited to 52 Mystery Boxes. Launching Veterans Day, November 11, 2026. Available only while supplies last.

More About the Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes:

Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes are limited-edition themed releases created for pen lovers who enjoy a great writing experience and a genuinely good surprise. Each edition brings together carefully selected writing instruments, inks, accessories, stationery, collectibles, or other finds around a new theme or occasion.

We provide enough clues to help you choose your adventure, but exact products, models, colors, and variations remain a mystery until your box arrives.

In the spirit of “NO PEEKING,” don't try to trick your favorite Pen Chalet employee into revealing the Mystery Box's secrets. That spoils all the fun.

But DO share once yours arrives. Everyone loves to see a good mystery solved in the end.

Pen Chalet Mystery Boxes are limited edition and available only while supplies last.

We don't accept returns on Mystery Boxes. However, if you have a problem with your pen or receive a defective item, that's a different story. Please contact customer service so we can help.

Here's to the stories worth telling, the people worth remembering, and the freedom to write our own.

Write on!

We are simultaneously dropping a 2nd Letters of Liberty Edition Pen Pals Mystery Box featuring the rollerball versions of these limited edition pens along with a slightly altered version of the "mystery" experience.


Available Sizes & Colors
The Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens usually ships within 1-3 business day unless otherwise specified or marked as special order.

* Special orders typically ship in 14-21 business days. However, occasionally due to manufacturer inventory, items can take up to 1-3 months. For a specific shipping estimate on your special order contact Customer Care.


Guaranteed Quality
Each Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Fountain Pens we sell is guaranteed to be genuine, authentic and will arrive brand new & unused!
expand

Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box Reviews

quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Overall rating:
4.8
out of 5
(20 reviews)

 
The mystery box introduced me to a new brand, Hinze. It is a smooth writer. I can use the two shimmer inks with my dip pens.
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I had been dithering over the Gioia Ocean pens - unable to decide which I Liked best. When I saw the Mystery Box which insinuated that the Gioia pen and Van Diemans ink would be included, I took a chance. So glad I did. The pen is beautiful - a mass of blue and aqua and white, surging like waves. The ink flow is very smooth. It's a nice solid pen, not too heavy, but certainly not slim (I prefer chunky pens, they're easier for me to hold). In addition to the pen and ink set, there was a bottle of 'Back in Black' ink, a pen rest, and a charm. I'm very pleased with the mystery box.
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I love the Mystery Boxes. Not only are they a decent value, but I've received items I probably wouldn't have chosen but found I enjoyed. Also, they're like getting a present in the mail from someone who gets my interests. Who doesn't love presents?
4 out of 5
overall rating 4 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 4 out of 5
function:
function rating 4 out of 5
style:
style rating 4 out of 5
value:
value value 4 out of 5
Pen Chalet mystery boxes are great and always fun! I was surprisingly shocked at the quality of the pen I received--it was fantastic gold nib!!! Pen Chalet also puts more variety and surprises into their boxes than other companies. The little touches communicate that this vendor appreciates its customers. Who knew that receiving my "ink oracle" would be so entertaining?
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
This was a great value. Only issues, and this does happen with mystery boxes, it was really designed for a woman - only reason for the low product style score. A lot of great stuff in the box - This was fun.
4 out of 5
overall rating 4 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I just got my mystery box today and it is absolutely beautiful. While the pen is gorgeous and one I don’t have, I think my favorite thing in the box is the “raining cats and dogs” pen rest. I’m a MASSIVE dog lover and this made me literally giggle when I unwrapped it.
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
It is always a bit hard to write a review for a "blind box" item as it has little to no confirmation of the quality of future boxes. But from the one I got, I was quite happy, I did felt a tinsy bit "cheated" when the sneak peak indicated that the fountain pen had a "gold nib". And while it is mostly true, it was a gold plated nib. Even with that, I am not disappointed. I wanted a pen from the brand and I got one at a slightly cheaper price than MSRP, all the rest of the box content were freebies that came with the pen. At least that's how I see it. As far as I am personally concerned, I will indulge myself in these mystery boxes in the future, they are fun and it is always fun to find a pen or item that you were always curious about but never buy yourself.
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Loved this box! The only way it could have gotten any better was to order in time to get a stub nib.Beautiful pen, love this brand.The ink was beautiful, the pen case was lovely and the pen stand was very unique and all the extras too. By far, my favorite box but have liked them all.
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Awesome, wonderfully curated, right up my alley, and an excellent value. I won’t spoil the surprise, but this is all stuff that’s been in my cart before that I hadn’t let myself get.Thanks so much!
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Wow!, I really WAS surprised! I was expecting something different and then getting the Black/Gold Tibaldi Bononia! I have seven Bononias and didn’t have this one. I love the pen - it writes beautifully with some Monteverde ink. A fine line for a Medium which is what I like. The pen rest is very nicely done - great workmanship. I also love the Aston pen sleeve - that’s my prefered sleeve - it softens and molds to any pen. Haven’t tried the inks yet!
5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
expand

FAQs about the Pen Chalet Pen Pals Mystery Box

Ask your own question:


Your Information:
(Name & email address are required.)


Please enter a vaild email address. Email will only be used to respond to your question.



If you would like us to call you, please enter your phone number.



Retail: $249.27i
Our Price: $160.25
Special On Sale!
Ships in 1-3 business day.


Nib Helper
Unsure which nib size to choose? We can help...


Ink Rewards Ink Rewards
X
Pen Chalet Ink Rewards
Fast & Easy way to earn FREE stuff!

  • Earn 1 "ink drop" for each $10 you spend.

  • Cash in your "ink drops" for free stuff!
The best part is it's absolutely free!

X
The term "Retail" price refers to the manufacturer's or supplier's suggested retail price for an item. The initially displayed Retail price is specific to a product with the selected default options/features. Please note that the Retail price for the selected product will be provided upon specifying it's color, options, and attributes, etc.

Please note that the Retail price reflects the prevailing market price or the regular retail price. It is common for products to be sold at lower prices than the Retail price due to various factors, including promotional events, discounts, market competition, or supplier agreements.

Learn more