Conklin All American Fountain Pens Reviews

quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Overall rating:
4.7
out of 5
(90 reviews)

 
Shhhh! Don't tell. One of these (Orange) is under the Christmas tree. (I have been a very good boy this year!) So I can't really rate it yet. I did peek and can tell you it's gorgeous! I'm so sure I'll love it I got the blue and the brown as gifts for friends. Super deal here at Pen Chalet. Could not pass it up!
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Gorgeous pen.
overall: 4 out of 5
overall rating 4 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I just love this Conklin All American Yellowstone fountain pen! I have small hands, but this big pen is really comfortable to write with and I mean for long periods, too. The nib is great. Now - the Yellowstone resin - lava lampish and the cool cadmium yellow and the white have some sheen. The solid brown color balances the shimmer in the yellow and white. I love this pen!
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
The Old Glory is just a big giant chunk of 'Merica. Beautiful material. And regardless of the immense size, this pen is very well balanced and does not weigh you down in the middle of a long writing session. The Section is well tapered and very comfortable. Overall, A big beautiful pen that is sure to grab everyone's attention!
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I wasn't a fan of cigar shaped pens. I like skinny pens because I have small hands. I was surprised by how comfortable this pen was. I have the fine and medium nib sizes and love them. Smooth writers. I like the colors too. I like that this website was the cheapest for this pen hence the reason I got 3.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Fantastic large Pen and my favorite Conklin. Might buy a couple more.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Brownstone 1.1 Stub / EF model. Test on Rhodia R, Tomoe River 56g and Midori notebook. Inked with Sailor Souten (Ef), Pelikan Onyx (Su).
Well, let's say that this pen hit me in the eye. From there, difficult to be objective but I will try to be a little anyway. The material is splendid and plays with the different intensities of light. My eyes do not get tired. The clip is out of the ordinary and contributes to the robust appearance without giving the impression of being faced with a mastondon. The black nib marries perfectly. I really like the style of this pen. Beautiful object.
The design is for me an excellent compromise between a Pelikan 800 (thinner but almost the same length) and a Edison Collier (bigger). It fits perfectly in my left hand of a relatively average size. He is not heavy. And contrary to what I read - we can fully consider using it every day, what I do.
One regret: no possibility in eyedropper.
I bought it with a Stub 1.1 pen and an EF. There too, good surprise. I had heard the worst about Conklin in terms of quality, especially at the level of nibs. If I consider both that I use, the surprise is pretty good. Would I have been lucky? In any case, there is nothing to complain about and compared to other brands, much more expensive, Conklin can be proud of this result. They made an excellent model, very homogeneous and pleasant to use.
As for the nibs, they were correctly adjusted, the flow very good, very soft. No problem starting. The only complaint is that - like all current nibs - they are a little big for their initial size. The EF would rather be for me a MF and as for the Stub well it would be a little too ... Stub. My taste for cursive nibs probably. No matter, it's not really an insurmountable problem to put them to his liking. See, change the nib # 6 by that of another brand as a FC nib grinded by MM.
In the end, I am really satisfied with this pen that I would advise in everyday use as it is easy and pleasant to use.
PS: I do not work for Conklin, I live in France between Burgundy and the Loire.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Got the Brownstone, love the weight and the color. writes smoothly, just love it! fast shipping and amazing deal thank you
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I love the look of this pen! I get all sorts of comments when I use it. Posting the cap makes it feel back heavy, so I usually just leave it off. It's a little thick, but not uncomfortable for my monster paws. It's a very smooth writer with my Noodler's Walnut ink, and does well on most paper. My only gripe is that the threads on the body for capping get uncomfortable when using it for a long session. Still, I love it!
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
The Conklin All American Brownstone w/ Med nib is a beautiful pen...well proportioned, balanced, fits comfortably in my hands and is lovely to look at, unfortunately I was less than happy with the actual writing experience; the ink did not flow, the nib suffered from Baby's bottom. After a call to Pen Chalet, Braden immediately diagnosed the problem and with out hesitation, shipped out a new nib. I received the new nib on Friday and began writing with the pen...now it writes as well as it looks, ink flows without a problem. I love it and the service from Braden.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5


Free Shipping
Free Shipping Spend $100 and get free shipping on all orders shipped anywhere within the United States.

Authorized Dealer
Authorized Dealer Pen Chalet is an authorized dealer of every brand we sell, so rest assured you are getting an authentic item.

We stand behind every item which we sell. If you are not satisfied let us know.

Shop With Confidence
Secure - Safe Shopping on PenChalet.com is Safe and Secure.

All of your information is encypted and transmitted using our Secure Sockets Layer(SSL) protocol.
Ink Rewards Ink Rewards
X
Pen Chalet Ink Rewards
Fast & Easy way to earn FREE stuff!

  • Earn 1 "ink drop" for each $10 you spend.

  • Cash in your "ink drops" for free stuff!
The best part is it's absolutely free!

X
The term "Retail" price refers to the manufacturer's or supplier's suggested retail price for an item. The initially displayed Retail price is specific to a product with the selected default options/features. Please note that the Retail price for the selected product will be provided upon specifying it's color, options, and attributes, etc.

Please note that the Retail price reflects the prevailing market price or the regular retail price. It is common for products to be sold at lower prices than the Retail price due to various factors, including promotional events, discounts, market competition, or supplier agreements.

Learn more