Retro 51 Vintage Metalsmith Fountain Pens Reviews

quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Overall rating:
4.7
out of 5
(20 reviews)

 
I choose the Mustang, and I love it! It's a heavy pen with intricate details, definitely not for someone with small hands, but it's sturdy and an eye-catcher.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I really enjoy the aesthetics of the Retro 51 Metalsmith "Corsair". The pen is a tad heavy and still a blast to use, but this one is being put into the collection for posterity.
overall: 4 out of 5
overall rating 4 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 4 out of 5
function:
function rating 4 out of 5
style:
style rating 4 out of 5
value:
value value 4 out of 5
This pen is fantastic. It’s lightweight and although sleek, it has the right thickness for a good grip. I recommend it!
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
One of my very favorite stub nibs. It's smooth but still gives me a sense of the paper I'm using, and reliably lays down a good swath of ink even if it's been sitting dormant over the weekend. I love a good weighty pen, and this feels substantial even when unposted. The line width variation is pleasing, and the burnished copper barrel makes me very happy every time I pick it up. Alas, most other Retro 51 pens I've seen are not visually appealing to me, but if they ever make more along these lines, I will snap them up.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Nice pen, quite attractive. It is metal so a bit on the heavy side, but that was expected. At the moment I'm having problems with the ink flow. Starts wet and then dries up in about one line on a page. If I can get that sorted out I'll be very pleased with the pen.
overall: 4 out of 5
overall rating 4 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 4 out of 5
function:
function rating 4 out of 5
style:
style rating 4 out of 5
value:
value value 4 out of 5
I ordered the Corsair in a Fine Point Nib, due to disappointing results from the EF Nib in the P-51 Mustang. The detail, quality & workmanship are all excellent on this Corsair. The rivets line-up when screwing on the cap.
The Fine Nib is an excellent and smooth writer. Wish the EF Nib on the P-51 Mustang wrote as nicely.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
Vintage Metalsmith Lincoln - Love this pen! Beautiful shading on the copper-colored metal. I ordered the stub nib and it behaves beautifully with the sparkle inks. Pen has a good weight in the hand and does not feel like a cheap metal. My first Retro pen and I'm impressed and very happy with this purchase!
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I love this pen! The 1.1 stub nib is nice and smooth. I love how the seams on the cap line up with the seams on the barrel.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
This is not only a classic design but a Great writing pen. I love it. And it is true that life is too short to carry an ugly pen.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5
I have the P51 Mustang med nib. Superb writer, smooth and good weight.
Using Pilot Iroshizuku Momiji ink.
overall: 5 out of 5
overall rating 5 out of 5
quality:
quality rating 5 out of 5
function:
function rating 5 out of 5
style:
style rating 5 out of 5
value:
value value 5 out of 5


Free Shipping
Free SHipping Spend $75 and get free shipping on all orders shipped anywhere within the United States.

Authorized Dealer
Authorized Dealer Pen Chalet is an authorized dealer of every brand we sell, so rest assured you are getting an authentic item.

We stand behind every item which we sell. If you are not satisfied let us know.

Shop With Confidence
Secure - Safe Shopping on PenChalet.com is Safe and Secure.

All of your information is encypted and transmitted using our Secure Sockets Layer(SSL) protocol.
Ink Rewards Ink Rewards
X
Pen Chalet Ink Rewards
Fast & Easy way to earn FREE stuff!

  • Earn 1 "ink drop" for each $10 you spend.

  • Cash in your "ink drops" for free stuff!
The best part is it's absolutely free!

X
The term "Retail" price refers to the manufacturer's or supplier's suggested retail price for an item. The initially displayed Retail price is specific to a product with the selected default options/features. Please note that the Retail price for the selected product will be provided upon specifying it's color, options, and attributes.

Please note that the Retail price reflects the prevailing market price or the regular retail price. It is common for products to be sold at lower prices than the Retail price due to various factors, including promotional events, discounts, market competition, or supplier agreements.